hi all, there was a recent reddit moderator mutiny where they shut down significant sections of the site, in protest over firing of a popular community relation manager.[a] reddit is currently valued at something like $~¼B dollars! its a complicated situation partly related to CEO Pao being just involved in a high-profie, lost lawsuit with Kleiner Perkins over gender discrimination.[b]
this is an area of big implications for the internet, namely collaborative systems, user generated content, and “collective intelligence”. sometimes the so-called wisdom of crowds can quickly turn into cyber mobs/ vigilantes.
user generated content fuels massive billiondollar corporations like Facebook, and even ultimately Google (which was invented basically to index it!); it also has big connections and crosspollinations to open science such as in “open/ public publishing” etc which is another key topic around here.
have been hanging out on another highly user-centric site for 3 eventful years, stackexchange, and have been immersed and studying its culture quite intensively and have talked to many different mods in chat over that time. (it also has a large volunteer moderator team probably numbering in the hundreds over all their many sites). they seem to be mostly ok with the site, but one can occasionally see the tension/ friction/ splits/ shearing with se management. stackexchange cofounder jeff atwood left it a few years ago and is working on a new online forum platform; he’s very innovative & have long felt theres a lot of room for continued innovation in this area, stackexchange is a remarkable, leading, topnotch collaborative system & hope he succeeds again elsewhere but it doesnt seem to be getting much traction so far.[f1][f2]
only in the last few years “800Lb gorilla” in user generated content, wikipedia, was in the news quite a bit,[c] such as about accuracy and hoax issues,[e] and there was some alarm about volunteers quitting.[d] but it seemed more at times like the mainstream media focusing on a commotion-du-jour and seeing it as a competitor, and now it seems now almost entirely off the mainstream media radar; the MSM now seems used to the idea. wikipedia has now matured, apparently now in middle age, and it has a somewhat different dynamic than in its “youth”.
❗ ❗ ❗ (update) Pao resigns! 😮
- 1. Should Reddit’s powerful mods be reined in?
- 2. Reddit Moderators Shut Down Parts of Site Over Employee’s Dismissal – The New York Times
- 3. Petition calling for Reddit’s CEO to step down reaches 14,000
- 4. Reddit in uproar after staff sacking – BBC News
- 5. Reddit campaign on Change.org tops 130k signatures after employee’s firing | Daily Mail Online
- 6. Reddit’s Meltdown Exposes Its Huge Conundrum | WIRED
- 7. Petition calling for Reddit boss Ellen Pao to resign hits 200,000 as she admits ‘we screwed up’ – Telegraph
- 8. Reddit Fired the Woman Trying to Save It – The Daily Beast
- 9. Reddit: can anyone clean up the mess behind ‘the front page of the internet’? | Technology | The Guardian
- 1. Reddit CEO Ellen Pao testifies against Silicon Valley Kleiner, Perkins, Caulfield & Byers | Daily Mail Online
- 2. Reddit CEO Ellen Pao LOSES gender bias case against Silicon Valley firm | Daily Mail Online
- 3. Pao Asks Court to Dismiss Kleiner’s $1M Reimbursement Claim | WIRED
- 4. It’d Be Crazy if VC Firms Didn’t Fix Their Gender Problem | WIRED
- 1. Is Wikipedia for Sale? | Motherboard
- 2. Meet the Stats Master Making Sense of Wikipedia’s Massive Data Trove | Wired Enterprise | Wired.com
- 3. The 36 People Who Run Wikipedia — Matter — Medium
- 4. You Can Look It Up: The Wikipedia Story – The Daily Beast
- 5. How Wikipedia Killed Encyclopedia Britannica – Business Insider
- 6. Elementary Mathematics on Wikipedia | Wikipediocracy
- 7. soft question – Are mathematical articles on Wikipedia reliable? – Mathematics Stack Exchange
- 1. 3 Charts That Show How Wikipedia Is Running Out of Admins – Robinson Meyer – The Atlantic
- 2. Have you stopped editing Wikipedia? And if so, is it doomed? | Technology | guardian.co.uk
- 3. Is this the decline of Wikipedia? A third of ‘staff’ have quit the site thanks to dumbed down software and auto-delete tools | Mail Online
- 4. Is Wikipedia in Decline? Scientists Search for Answers in Wikipedia’s Numbers | Fast Company
- 5. Report claims Wikipedia losing editors in droves
- 6. Kids these days: the quality of new Wikipedia editors over time — Wikimedia blog
- 7. The Daily Dot – The battle to destroy Wikipedia’s biggest sockpuppet army
- 8. The Decline of Wikipedia: Even As More People Than Ever Rely on It, Fewer People Create It | MIT Technology Review
- 9. Volunteers Log Off as Wikipedia Ages – WSJ.com
- 10. Wikipedia Is Losing Contributors | News & Opinion | PCMag.com
- 11. Wikipedia’s Labor Squeeze and Its Consequences Eric Goldman
- 1. USATODAY.com – A false Wikipedia ‘biography’
- 2. USATODAY.com – It’s online, but is it true?
- 3. Wikipedia hoaxster found, but a solution for Wikipedia is still lacking | Ars Technica
- 4. BBC NEWS | Technology | Wikipedia joker eats humble pie
- 5. Behind the greatest Wikipedia hoax ever pulled
- 1. Discourse
- 2. StackExchange Founder Vows to Reinvent Online Discourse | Wired Enterprise | Wired.com
- 3. Open Collaborative Mathematics over the Internet – Three Examples | Combinatorics and more
- 4. New Software Fuels New Knowledge | Don Tapscott
- 5. SciCast Predict
- 6. Foresight Exchange
- 7. Forget The Wisdom of Crowds; Neurobiologists Reveal The Wisdom Of The Confident | MIT Technology Review
- 8. Collective Intelligence predicted winners of Super Bowl, Stanley Cup, and NBA finals! – UNANIMOUS A.I.
- 9. Wiki Inventor Sticks a Fork in His Baby | Wired Enterprise | Wired.com
Pingback: cyberspace unleashed 2015, huge link pile | Turing Machine